Middle East Policy has been one of the world’s most cited publications on the region since its inception in 1982, and our Breaking Analysis series makes high-quality, diverse analysis available to a broader audience.
Khalaf Ahmad Al Habtoor
Guest Commentary
June 4, 2018
Both sides in this enduring conflict have been failed by leaders and Western intermediaries. Summits, conferences, accords and a roadmap going nowhere have been a waste of time and effort. Earlier attempts at finding solutions brokered by Former US Presidents Jimmy Carter and Bill Clinton were genuine but were stymied. Those that followed were either fig leaves or half-hearted.
Today, there is not only ‘nothing on the table’, there is no table. When Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu announced there would never be a Palestinian state on his watch – a statement he later retracted for international consumption – he meant every word. Just days ago, he approved the construction of 2,000 more settler homes on the West Bank.
And, quite frankly, I am beginning to think US President Donald Trump’s blueprint for peace is a figment of his imagination.
There is plenty of blame to apportion but regurgitating past errors of judgment has been done over and over again. It is beyond time for a new page to be opened in this unending book of horrors. How long must we go on rehashing and repeating more than 50 years-worth of mistakes?
Presidents, prime ministers, Middle East envoys and UN Secretary Generals, however well-meaning, have achieved precisely nothing. Relations between Israel and the Palestinian National Authority are on the rocks. Rockets and missiles fly both ways over Gaza.
I am convinced that peace will not come from the top down but rather requires grassroots movements on the lines of Peace Now, established by Israeli reservists in 1978 to advocate for a two-state solution. Once popular commanding a huge following among Israelis it is now on the fringe; its activists subjected to death threats.
The climate has worsened since the movement’s heyday, currently dominated by fear, hatred and a thirst for revenge. Those destructive emotions need to change. Trust between the two peoples needs to be built brick by brick; they should learn to see each other as fellow human beings with the same hopes and dreams. Peace Now’s philosophy must be revived in the hearts of minds of not only Israelis but also Palestinians.
Israelis and Palestinians must put a lid on the past no matter how painful and bloody, else suffocate what could be a bright future. Yesterday is just fodder for history books. The only path of any value is forward, a path that takes us away from dark shadows into the light.
What Palestinians have to gain from a peaceful conclusion to this conflict is well known. The tiny spark of hope that gave them the courage to carry on is all but stifled replaced by desperation, evidenced by recent mass protests in Gaza resulting in dozens of deaths and thousands of injuries.
Their courage is beyond reproach but other than placing their plight on the international front burner for a brief moment in time, such demonstrations are exercises in futility at a great cost to those who took part.
Yes, Israel’s reputation for brutality has taken another knock. European states and even sectors of the American Jewish community are outraged. Many countries are beginning to consider Israel a pariah state. However, as long as it remains under a White House umbrella it will never be held accountable.
Appealing to Netanyahu or Trump to come up with solutions in good faith is pointless. They only understand the language of force. My appeal is directed at the Israeli people so used to the status quo that they may be unaware that reconciliation with stable, prosperous Arab states on condition Palestinians get their rights will provide them with untold benefits, including:
Inflows of investments from the GCC and other Arab countries to boost Israel’s economy translating to new business opportunities, improved infrastructure, greater opportunities and prosperity.
The ability to travel and be welcomed as tourists throughout most of the Middle East.
A reduction in anti-Semitism exacerbated in part by occupation.
A potential end to the conscription of young Israelis and mandatory reserve duty until the age of 40.
An exchange of talent and technologies.
Mutual cultural and social interactions.
The end of aggression and loathing.
Security and intelligence cooperation buffering Iran’s belligerence.
I would ask Israelis to set aside their long-held prejudices and dig deep to see what is in their interests. The same goes for Arabs.
Think about your children and grandchildren. Do not indoctrinate them with your fears and hatreds. Do not pollute the minds of future generations impacting their lives! Young people deserve to be carefree not made to wear uniforms and carry weapons. Allow them to formulate their own views. Give them a chance to move forward together free from the weight of your emotional baggage and bad experiences. Changing attitudes is a crucial prerequisite for Israelis and Arabs to live together with mutual respect on the same soil.
Like it or not, the Israeli state is recognized by the United Nations and the world at large. Israel boasts high-calibre university graduates, ground-breaking inventions and cutting-edge research. Better to deal with it than fruitlessly wishing it away. Israel with its nuclear weapons and military might is going nowhere.
Whereas I have championed a two-state solution throughout most of my life, organizing fundraisers and conferences, I am a realist. The chance of that happening is gone other than the creation of another enclave like Gaza, a demilitarized entity with no control over its own borders. I can only conclude that Israelis and Palestinians must coexist in one state as equal citizens with the same rights.
We all prayed for Palestine to be liberated and for Palestinians to have their own state, but is that achievable now or is the idea simple wishful thinking within our stubbornly romantic minds? Wishful thinking will not permit the Palestinian people to live in dignity and security without fear.
Let us shift our thinking towards a logical solution that will secure a better future for our nations, for Arab and Israeli youth and especially for those young Palestinians born in conflict who deserve the same chances enjoyed by their peers everywhere.
Israelis and Palestinians should revolt against the useless old leadership playbooks keeping them on different sides of the fence. Tear down those figurative and material walls. People power could be a game changer. The men in suits bent on consolidating power have let you down. Peace engendered by the very people who have the most to gain (and to lose) could work where all else has failed.
Middle East Policy has been one of the world’s most cited publications on the region since its inception in 1982, and our Breaking Analysis series makes high-quality, diverse analysis available to a broader audience.
Partner with the Council
We appreciate any support towards the Middle East Policy Council to help educate Americans on the political, economic and cultural issues that affect U.S. interests in the Middle East.
One of the most frequently cited journals on the Middle East in the field of international affairs, Middle East Policy has been engaging thoughtful minds for more than 40 years with high-quality, diverse analysis on the region.
Khalaf Ahmad Al Habtoor
Guest Commentary
June 4, 2018
Both sides in this enduring conflict have been failed by leaders and Western intermediaries. Summits, conferences, accords and a roadmap going nowhere have been a waste of time and effort. Earlier attempts at finding solutions brokered by Former US Presidents Jimmy Carter and Bill Clinton were genuine but were stymied. Those that followed were either fig leaves or half-hearted.
Today, there is not only ‘nothing on the table’, there is no table. When Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu announced there would never be a Palestinian state on his watch – a statement he later retracted for international consumption – he meant every word. Just days ago, he approved the construction of 2,000 more settler homes on the West Bank.
And, quite frankly, I am beginning to think US President Donald Trump’s blueprint for peace is a figment of his imagination.
There is plenty of blame to apportion but regurgitating past errors of judgment has been done over and over again. It is beyond time for a new page to be opened in this unending book of horrors. How long must we go on rehashing and repeating more than 50 years-worth of mistakes?
Presidents, prime ministers, Middle East envoys and UN Secretary Generals, however well-meaning, have achieved precisely nothing. Relations between Israel and the Palestinian National Authority are on the rocks. Rockets and missiles fly both ways over Gaza.
I am convinced that peace will not come from the top down but rather requires grassroots movements on the lines of Peace Now, established by Israeli reservists in 1978 to advocate for a two-state solution. Once popular commanding a huge following among Israelis it is now on the fringe; its activists subjected to death threats.
The climate has worsened since the movement’s heyday, currently dominated by fear, hatred and a thirst for revenge. Those destructive emotions need to change. Trust between the two peoples needs to be built brick by brick; they should learn to see each other as fellow human beings with the same hopes and dreams. Peace Now’s philosophy must be revived in the hearts of minds of not only Israelis but also Palestinians.
Israelis and Palestinians must put a lid on the past no matter how painful and bloody, else suffocate what could be a bright future. Yesterday is just fodder for history books. The only path of any value is forward, a path that takes us away from dark shadows into the light.
What Palestinians have to gain from a peaceful conclusion to this conflict is well known. The tiny spark of hope that gave them the courage to carry on is all but stifled replaced by desperation, evidenced by recent mass protests in Gaza resulting in dozens of deaths and thousands of injuries.
Their courage is beyond reproach but other than placing their plight on the international front burner for a brief moment in time, such demonstrations are exercises in futility at a great cost to those who took part.
Yes, Israel’s reputation for brutality has taken another knock. European states and even sectors of the American Jewish community are outraged. Many countries are beginning to consider Israel a pariah state. However, as long as it remains under a White House umbrella it will never be held accountable.
Appealing to Netanyahu or Trump to come up with solutions in good faith is pointless. They only understand the language of force. My appeal is directed at the Israeli people so used to the status quo that they may be unaware that reconciliation with stable, prosperous Arab states on condition Palestinians get their rights will provide them with untold benefits, including:
I would ask Israelis to set aside their long-held prejudices and dig deep to see what is in their interests. The same goes for Arabs.
Think about your children and grandchildren. Do not indoctrinate them with your fears and hatreds. Do not pollute the minds of future generations impacting their lives! Young people deserve to be carefree not made to wear uniforms and carry weapons. Allow them to formulate their own views. Give them a chance to move forward together free from the weight of your emotional baggage and bad experiences. Changing attitudes is a crucial prerequisite for Israelis and Arabs to live together with mutual respect on the same soil.
Like it or not, the Israeli state is recognized by the United Nations and the world at large. Israel boasts high-calibre university graduates, ground-breaking inventions and cutting-edge research. Better to deal with it than fruitlessly wishing it away. Israel with its nuclear weapons and military might is going nowhere.
Whereas I have championed a two-state solution throughout most of my life, organizing fundraisers and conferences, I am a realist. The chance of that happening is gone other than the creation of another enclave like Gaza, a demilitarized entity with no control over its own borders. I can only conclude that Israelis and Palestinians must coexist in one state as equal citizens with the same rights.
We all prayed for Palestine to be liberated and for Palestinians to have their own state, but is that achievable now or is the idea simple wishful thinking within our stubbornly romantic minds? Wishful thinking will not permit the Palestinian people to live in dignity and security without fear.
Let us shift our thinking towards a logical solution that will secure a better future for our nations, for Arab and Israeli youth and especially for those young Palestinians born in conflict who deserve the same chances enjoyed by their peers everywhere.
Israelis and Palestinians should revolt against the useless old leadership playbooks keeping them on different sides of the fence. Tear down those figurative and material walls. People power could be a game changer. The men in suits bent on consolidating power have let you down. Peace engendered by the very people who have the most to gain (and to lose) could work where all else has failed.